This is an interesting discussion. I do not have the time to involve myself in it so I will not be able to straighten all of you out. However suffice it to say most believers say that God exists outside of time, but how is this really possible? If God created the universe, then there was a moment when God existed alone, before he created the universe, and then there was a moment when God exists with the universe, after he created it. But you cannot have concepts of "before" and "after" without time. In order for God to do anything, there must be a time before, and a time after he does it. Therefore, it is logically impossible for God to exist outside of time.